Does a Postnuptial Agreement Hold Up in Court in CA?

Get the help you need!

Meet Jennifer and David, a happily married couple in California. They’ve been together for five years, and during this time, they’ve both experienced significant personal and professional growth. Jennifer’s business has taken off, and David has recently received a substantial inheritance from his family. While they’re excited about their future together, they also recognize the importance of having clear financial boundaries and protecting their individual assets.

During a recent conversation with friends, they learn about postnuptial agreements and how a postnup can provide a sense of security and clarity for married couples. Intrigued, Jennifer starts to wonder, “Could a postnuptial agreement be right for us? And if we do decide to create one, does a postnuptial agreement hold up in court?”

If you find yourself in a situation similar to Jennifer and David’s, you’re not alone. Many married couples in California consider a post marriage agreement for various reasons as we’ll discuss in this blog. However, for a postnuptial agreement to be valid and enforceable, it must adhere to California’s legal requirements.

In this blog post, we’ll cover what postnuptial agreements are, how they differ from prenuptial agreements, and the legal requirements they must meet to be valid. We’ll also discuss the circumstances that may invalidate a postnuptial agreement and the factors California courts consider when evaluating their enforceability.

By the end of this blog, you’ll have a clearer understanding of whether a postnuptial agreement is right for your situation and what steps you need to take to ensure it will hold up in court. 

What is a Postnuptial Agreement?

A postnuptial agreement is a legal contract entered into by you and your spouse after you’re already married. Unlike a prenuptial agreement, which is signed before the wedding, a postnuptial agreement is created during your marriage. You may choose to enter into a postnuptial agreement for various reasons, such as:

  • Clarifying financial responsibilities and property division
  • Protecting individual assets or inheritances
  • Addressing changes in financial circumstances during the marriage
  • Establishing spousal support obligations

Legal Requirements for a Valid Postnuptial Agreement in California

In California, there isn’t a single law that directly addresses postnuptial agreements. Instead, these agreements are guided by a combination of general contract rules, decisions from courts, and certain marriage laws. Specifically, the California Family Code § 721 is important because it requires spouses to treat each other with honesty and fairness in any agreement, including those made after marriage. 

This principle, although it doesn’t explicitly mention postnuptial agreements, sets the expectation for trust and fairness. Also, the way the law treats agreements made before marriage (California Family Code § 1615) provides insights into what’s expected for agreements made after marriage. In short, while there’s no specific postnuptial agreement law in California, existing laws on contracts and marriage help ensure these agreements are made with clarity and fairness. Within this context, here are the essential requirements for a valid postnuptial agreement in California:

  1. Written agreement: The agreement must be in writing and signed by both you and your spouse.
  2. Voluntary execution: You and your spouse must enter into the agreement voluntarily, without duress or coercion.
  3. Full disclosure: Both parties must fully disclose their assets and liabilities to ensure a fair agreement.
  4. Not unconscionable: The agreement cannot be grossly unfair or one-sided at the time of signing.
  5. Notarization or attestation: The agreement should be notarized or signed by witnesses to further validate its authenticity.
  6. Separate legal counsel: It’s strongly recommended that you and your spouse have separate legal representation to protect your individual interests.

Circumstances That May Invalidate a Postnuptial Agreement

Even if your postnuptial agreement meets the above requirements, certain circumstances can render it invalid:

  • Duress or coercion: If you or your spouse were forced or pressured into signing the agreement, it may be deemed invalid.
  • Fraud or misrepresentation: If either party provides false or incomplete information about their assets or liabilities, the agreement could be invalidated.
  • Unconscionability: If the agreement is found to be extremely unfair to one party at the time of enforcement, a court may refuse to uphold it.
  • Violation of public policy: If the agreement violates public policy or includes illegal provisions, it may be considered void.

Enforceability of Postnuptial Agreements in California Courts

While a prenuptial agreement becomes valid on the date it’s signed, a postnuptial agreement must be approved by the court to be enforceable. This approval process typically occurs when the agreement needs to be enforced, such as during divorce or legal separation proceedings.

When a couple decides to divorce or legally separate, and they have a postnuptial agreement in place, they must submit the agreement to the court as part of the divorce or separation process. At this point, the court will review the agreement to ensure that it meets the legal requirements for enforceability.

California courts evaluate the enforceability of postnuptial agreements based on several factors, including:

  • Compliance with legal formalities: The agreement must adhere to all legal requirements, such as being in writing, signed by both parties, and notarized or witnessed.
  • Circumstances surrounding the agreement’s execution: The court will consider whether the agreement was entered into voluntarily and free from duress, coercion, or undue influence.

If the court finds the agreement to be one-sided, unfair, or not in compliance with legal requirements, it may refuse to enforce the postnuptial agreement.

To ensure that your postnuptial agreement is legally enforceable and follows California law, it’s advisable  to consult with a post nup lawyer. An experienced attorney can guide you through the process, help you create a document that meets all legal requirements, and increase the likelihood that your agreement will withstand court scrutiny.

Modifying or Challenging a Postnuptial Agreement

If you believe your postnuptial agreement is invalid or unfair, you may seek to modify or challenge it in court. The burden of proof falls on the party challenging the agreement to demonstrate grounds for modification or invalidation, such as duress, fraud, or unconscionability. If successful, the court may either modify the agreement or declare it entirely unenforceable.

The Importance of Seeking Legal Counsel

Given the complexity of postnuptial agreements and the potential consequences of an invalid or unfair agreement, it’s essential to seek legal counsel when considering a postnuptial agreement in California. An experienced post nup lawyer can help you:

  • Ensure your agreement meets all legal requirements
  • Protect your individual rights and interests
  • Navigate complex legal issues and negotiate fair terms

Postnuptial agreements can provide valuable protection and clarity for married couples in California, but they must be carefully drafted and executed to withstand legal scrutiny. By understanding the legal requirements, potential pitfalls, and the importance of seeking legal guidance, you can create a postnuptial agreement that will hold up in court and serve your interests well. 

Considering a Postnuptial Agreement in California? Protect Your Rights and Interests

If you and your spouse are contemplating a postnuptial agreement in California, it’s crucial to ensure that your agreement is legally valid, fair, and enforceable. As you’ve learned from this blog, postnuptial agreements must adhere to specific legal requirements and are subject to court scrutiny. Creating a postnuptial agreement that meets all the necessary criteria can be a daunting task, but with the right legal guidance, you can confidently proceed with this important step in your marriage.

The experienced postnuptial agreement attorneys at Seabrook Law Offices are here to help. We can guide you through the process of creating a postnuptial agreement that meets California’s legal standards and protects your rights and interests.

Our knowledgeable team will work closely with you to understand your unique situation, provide personalized advice, and draft a postnuptial agreement that addresses your specific needs and goals. We’ll ensure that your agreement is fair, legally sound, and designed to withstand court scrutiny if ever challenged.

Take the first step towards securing your financial future and protecting your assets. Contact Seabrook Law Offices at (408) 560-4487 or complete our secure online form to schedule a consultation with our skilled postnuptial agreement lawyers. Let us help you create a postnuptial agreement that provides the clarity, security, and peace of mind you and your spouse need for a strong and thriving marriage.

Before you go, we invite you to stay connected with us on Instagram, Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook, and YouTube for more insights and updates.

Copyright © 2024. Seabrook Law Offices. All rights reserved.

The information in this blog post (“post”) is provided for general informational purposes only and may not reflect the current law in your jurisdiction. No information in this post should be construed as legal advice from the individual author or the law firm, nor is it intended to be a substitute for legal counsel on any subject matter. No reader of this post should act or refrain from acting based on any information included in or accessible through this post without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from a lawyer licensed in the recipient’s state, country, or other appropriate licensing jurisdiction.

Seabrook Law Offices
6840 Via Del Oro, Suite 265
San Jose, CA 95119
(408) 560-4487

Seabrook Law Offices
2201 Walnut Ave, Suite 190 
Fremont, CA 94538
(510) 800-8288

Signup for new blog notifications!

* Required Fields
We respect your privacy. The information you provide will be used to answer your question or to schedule an appointment if requested.

Contact Us

Please type your message below and we will get back to you asap.
About Us
* Required Fields
We respect your privacy. The information you provide will be used to answer your question or to schedule an appointment if requested.

Our Practice Areas

Family Law Attorney in San Jose, CA 95119 - Family Law In San Jose

Family Law

Family Law is among the most challenging areas of practice. Along with…

Mediation - Divorce & Family Lawyer - San Jose, CA


Ending a marriage is never an easy process, and it’s even more …

Personal Injury Attorneys in San Jose, CA 95119 | Personal Injury FAQs

Personal Injury

Seabrook Law Offices the Personal Injury Specialists.
We will try our…

Divorce Lawyer in San Jose, CA 95119 – Attorney For Divorce in CA


A divorce is possibly the most stressful thing you can go through in life.